The Best Steakhouses in The Carmel, NY Area

When you’re looking for a sizzling, juicy steak to sink your teeth into, you don’t want to settle for any little slab of meat. You want something seasoned to perfection with just the right amount of marbling to savor every bite. Many excellent establishments can help you cure your craving for a quality cutlet in the Carmel, New York area. No matter your cut choice, you can get the best value for your money if you know the right places. Read on to discover our list of the best steakhouses in the Carmel, New York area.

McCarthy’s Grill House

Image via Flickr under CC BY 2.0 by adactio

McCarthy’s Grill House is a hidden gem that locals love. It is conveniently located at 374 NY-52, in the heart of Carmel. They have a friendly staff that helps make your dining experience relaxed and enjoyable. Their crisp linen tablecloths and comfortable seating arrangement lend an air to the atmosphere that instantly puts guests at ease. They offer a daily menu, have rotating seasonal items, and provide gluten-free options upon request. They provide various menu options, ranging from dinner salads, appetizers, chicken entrees, seafood, and burgers. What you want to try is their selection of steaks.

Available on their daily menu, they have everything from 10- or 16-ounce New York strip steaks to Teriyaki and Cajun steaks. However, for a pop of flavor in your mouth like no other, we suggest you order the sizzling garlic steak. It is a generous serving of quality beef cooked to perfection. Served with a crispy salad and warm bread, the meal is a satisfying marriage of flavors. Follow up your main course with one of their international coffees. We favor the Nutty Irishman. It is a tasty brew with Baileys and Frangelico.

They are open Monday through Friday from 12 p.m. to 3 p.m and are accessible from anywhere in Putnam County. After purchasing your new vehicle with us, head over to McCarthy’s for a celebration steak. They even offer catering services for your next anniversary party—Call 845-222-6012 for details.

V&V Italian Steakhouse

The 30-minute drive over to Newburgh is worth it for the savory steaks you’ll find at V&V Steakhouse. Our friendly staff raves about the ambiance at this fine establishment. The upscale decor lends a touch of elegance to your dining experience, making this a perfect restaurant for a first date or surprise engagement proposal. They have generous servings that are adequately priced for the amount of food you are plated, the flavorful goodness in each bite, and the quality service you receive.

They use traditional Italian seasoning to enhance the flavors of their menu items and are consistent with the quality of food and service they provide. They serve their guests Omaha steaks, ensuring only the best farm-to-table ingredients meet your plate. Many customers rave about the T-Bone steak, an excellent option for the hungriest of diners! Those looking for something lighter offer a fresh Mixed Greens Field Salad with fresh diced tomato, red onion, and a homemade balsamic dressing. Other flavorful options include Pollo Principessa, a breaded chicken with lemon and white wine butter sauce.

Next to the bridge, you’ll find them at 34 Plank Road in Newburgh, New York. Just don’t go on Mondays, because they’re closed.

Luigi’s Famiglia Cucina

Luigi’s Famiglia Cucina seems like a phenomenal place to savor the flavors of Italy and get some fantastic pasta. And it is. Their welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff immediately treat guests like family to start a pleasant and impressive dining experience. Known for serving some of the best pizza in Carmel, the hardworking owner of this family business uses an authentic wood-fired brick oven to prepare many meals.

You’d be doing yourself a disservice if you didn’t try their Ribeye steak at least once in your life. It is tender, succulent, savory, and cooked so perfectly it melts in your mouth. They serve the steak with sauteed broccoli, carrots, and roasted potatoes in place of pasta. With this filling meal, you’ll be happy you skipped out on the pasta for some steak. Top off your meal with a cappuccino to ease digestion, and you’ll be a happy carnivore.

You can order online for delivery services or utilize their carry-out options. Luigi’s will also be happy to cater your next event. Call 845-225-4000 for details and information on placing an order or making a reservation.

Carmel Diner

Make an appointment for an early morning routine service on your vehicle, then drive over Carmel Diner at 63 Gleneida Avenue. This family-owned and operated establishment sits at the heart of Carmel and has for the past 25 years. They offer a family-friendly dining experience with a diverse menu that will satisfy little tummies, picky eaters, and enormous appetites. Their versatile seating can accommodate single diners at the traditional diner bar, large parties, or a couple looking for an intimate dining experience.

Like an authentic diner, breakfast proves to be the most important meal of the day and is available all day. Whether you arrive at 7 a.m. or 7 p.m. We suggest you opt for their steak and eggs. Loyal customers swear it’s the best they’ve ever had.

Carmel Diner is open daily from 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. and is ready to serve you. They offer dine-in services and are equally happy to prepare your meal for you to enjoy in the comfort of your own home. Curbside pickup and no-contact delivery are both available. You can even order online at your convenience. Carmel Diner is proud to offer catering services to the community and provide you and your guests with anything on their menu. Inquire using their form or call 845-225-5000 for information.

There it is! Meadowland of Carmel has just shared with you our list of the best steakhouses in the Carmel, New York area. Did you find a new enticing steakhouse to hit up for your next celebration? Did we miss a favorite of yours? Please leave a message and let us know your spot for savory steaks. We’ll be happy to include your suggestions on our list.