Sink Your Teeth into the Best Burger Restaurants Around Carmel, NY

Whether you like your burger piled high with toppings, smothered in cheese, or kept simple and juicy, there’s no shortage of amazing burger joints near Carmel, NY. This charming Hudson Valley town is surrounded by local eateries that serve up everything from classic diner-style burgers to gourmet creations bursting with bold flavor.

If you’re craving a burger that hits the spot, we’ve done the tasty legwork for you. Within a 30-minute drive of Carmel, you’ll find a mix of hometown diners, laid-back pubs, and upscale restaurants—all dishing out mouthwatering burgers worth the trip (or the takeout). Let’s dive into some of the top spots where burger dreams come true.

Bliss Dairy Bar&Grill – Mahopac, NY

A short ride down the road in Mahopac brings you to Bliss Dairy Bar&Grill, a stylish American bistro known for fresh ingredients and flavorful dishes—and yes, that includes seriously good burgers. This spot puts a gourmet twist on the classics, and the cozy, modern vibe makes it perfect for date nights or dinners with friends. Their outdoor patio is a hit in the warmer months, and the staff always makes you feel like a regular. If you’re looking for a burger with a little flair, Bliss Dairy Bar&Grilldelivers.

McCarthy’s Family Eatery – Carmel, NY

McCarthy’s Family Eatery is another Carmel staple, bringing comfort food to a whole new level. Their burgers are thick, juicy, and loaded with toppings—from crispy bacon and melty cheese to sautéed onions and house sauces. With fast service, a laid-back atmosphere, and a big menu of other American classics, McCarthy’s is a go-to for a casual lunch or dinner. Locals love it, and after one bite, you’ll see why.

Carmel Diner – Carmel, NY

Few things go better together than burgers and diners, and Carmel Diner is proof of that. Open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, this classic spot has a great burger lineup that includes everything from a basic cheeseburger to a towering double bacon burger. Each burger is made fresh and served with crispy fries or onion rings, just like you’d expect at a proper diner. The retro vibe and friendly service make it an easy favorite, especially when you’re in the mood for comfort food. It’s an ideal pit stop any day of the week.

Fiddler’s Green Pub – Carmel, NY

If you’re looking for a relaxed pub setting with burgers that pack flavor and attitude, head over to Fiddler’s Green. This Irish-style pub has a cozy atmosphere, friendly bartenders, and a burger menu that locals rave about. You’ll also find spicy options, hearty patties, and vegetarian alternatives. With cold beer on tap and plenty of TVs for sports fans, this place is great for unwinding with a burger and a brew.

Burger Bliss Around Carmel

Whether you’re a fan of classic diner-style burgers or you crave bold flavors with gourmet toppings, Carmel and its neighboring towns have a burger spot just for you. 

And while you’re out exploring Carmel’s best burger joints, don’t forget to check out Meadowland of Carmel CDJR. Just like a great burger spot, they’re all about quality, customer service, and making sure you leave happy, whether you’re driving off in a new Ram 1500 or just stopping by to browse.

Image Credit: Low-angle of burgers by Niklas Rhose, Licensed by Unsplash License

Tags: Local
Posted in Local, Local Restaurants | No Comments »